Getting Bates Numbers Right: Hyphens and Hyphen-minuses

Getting Bates Numbers Right: Hyphens and Hyphen-minuses

Recently I received a PDF of list of Bates numbers that I had to look up in a Relativity workspace. I converted the PDF to an Excel spreadsheet using Adobe Acrobat, and copied the column containing the Bates numbers into the field for the document identifier in Relativity. Unexpectedly, the Bates numbers which contained hyphens did not come up in the search results. What went wrong?

One of the Bates numbers from the exhibit list that I couldn't find was composed of these characters [note: these are not real Bates numbers, but the hyphens are]:


However, the Relativity workspace did contain a Bates number as a document identifier that was composed of these characters:


What's the difference? It's hard to see but the hyphen or dash between the letter prefix and the six digit number is different. See this analysis in Excel:

The IF . . . THEN formula shows the two Bates numbers are not actually the same. The UNICODE formula reveals that the two hyphens are actually distinct characters.

Unicode 45 is the hyphen-minus character used in cell B1. Unicode 8208 is a regular hyphen used in cell A1. These characters can be read differently by document review platforms and text editors.

Be sure to also account for en dashes – (unicode 8211 entered with ALT CODE 0150) and em dashes — (unicode 8212 entered with ALT CODE 0151).

Contact Me With Your Litigation Support Questions:

  • Twitter Long Shadow

© 2015 by Sean O'Shea . Proudly created with